By using this website, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.

Pros and Cons of Different Dog Training Collars

By Jason Wright

June 22, 2023

Whether you have a puppy or an older dog, as a dog owner, it’s your responsibility to ensure that your pet is properly trained. This ensures the safety of not only your dog but also your family, friends and other dogs and people you encounter daily.

Treats, clickers and sturdy leashes can all be valuable tools when training your pet; however, having the right training collar can make a world of difference during your training sessions. While some may have reservations about using a dog training collar, it is important to understand that when used properly, these collars can be safe and effective tools in promoting positive behaviour and fostering a strong and healthy bond with your dog. 

With so many collars to choose from, it’s no surprise that some owners and trainers will prefer certain types of training collars over others. To help you make an informed decision as to which training collar will work best for you and your pet, we’ll break down the benefits of each option and highlight the collar our trained professionals use throughout this blog post. 

Why Use a Dog Training Collar? 

A dog training collar is a valuable aid in teaching your dog obedience, improving behaviour, and promoting safety, especially during training sessions when your dog is still learning proper behaviour and commands. 

As we’ve mentioned before, treats and other tools can be effective aids in helping to relay positive reinforcement after your dog performs a command or a trick. However, it's important to use a dog collar to keep your dog engaged and their attention on you, as well as to help notify your dog when they are misbehaving. 

Here are some key reasons why you should consider using a training collar:

  1. Communication: A training collar allows for clear and consistent communication between you and your dog, establishing a common language and facilitating better communication during training sessions. This tool also helps your pet understand commands and expectations more effectively. 
  2. Control: Using a training collar gives you better control over your dog's behaviour, especially in distracting or potentially dangerous situations. It provides you with the ability to redirect their attention and reinforce desired behaviours, ensuring their safety and the safety of those around them.
  3. Reinforcement: Training collars provide a means to reinforce positive behaviours and discourage unwanted behaviours. Whether teaching basic obedience commands or addressing specific behavioural issues, a training collar can be an invaluable tool in shaping your dog's behaviour and teaching them appropriate responses.
  4. Versatility: Dog training collars come in various types, each suited for specific training goals and individual dogs. This versatility allows you to choose the collar that best aligns with your training objectives and your dog's needs. From simple flat buckle collars to more advanced e-collars, there is a collar available for every training scenario.

Types of Dog Training Collars 

Some trainers or owners prefer to use one type of training collar over the other, and this can also be dependent on the dog and its behaviour. While we all have our preferences, it’s important to understand that whoever is working with the dog and using the collar should be well-trained. 

As a reminder, training collars need to be properly conditioned to your pet so that they understand what it means and how it works; before using it to correct poor behaviour. In addition, training collars should never be used to inflict pain or punish your pet. Instead, they are an aid used to help communicate with your dog, helping to highlight what behaviour is inappropriate and should be avoided. So, proper training and understanding of using the collar are necessary before any sessions with your dog begin.

Here is a list of some of the available collars:

Flat Buckle Collar: 

This traditional collar is made of sturdy material with a buckle for easy fastening. It works by providing a means to attach identification tags and a leash. While it offers limited control, it is suitable for dogs with minimal behavioural issues.

The pros of a Flat Buckle Collar include: 

  • Lightweight and comfortable for everyday use.
  • Easy to put on and remove, making it convenient for walks and outings.
  • Suitable for dogs with minimal behavioural issues.

The cons of this type of collar include:

  • Limited control over strong or stubborn dogs that require more guidance.
  • Ineffective for dogs that pull excessively on the leash, as it lacks additional control features.

If you have a dog with severe behavioural issues, this type of collar is not recommended.

Martingale Collar: 

Also known as a limited-slip collar, this type of collar consists of a wide loop that tightens when the dog pulls, but only to a certain extent. This collar prevents dogs from slipping out and offers more control without excessive pressure on the neck.

The pros of a Martingale or Limited-Slip collar include:

  • It prevents dogs from slipping out of the collar, providing extra security.
  • Suitable for dogs with medium-level behavioural issues, such as pulling or lunging.

Cons of this type of collar include:

  • Improper use or incorrect sizing may cause discomfort or injury.
  • Not ideal for dogs with respiratory issues or short-nosed breeds due to potential breathing restrictions.

If you’re unsure whether a limited-slip collar could be used on your pet, be sure to speak with a trained professional before using it.

Head Halter: 

Like a horse's halter, this collar fits around the dog's head, providing control by redirecting their focus and discouraging pulling. It is suitable for dogs that require gentle control or have leash aggression.

The pros of a Head Halter include:

  • Offers excellent control by redirecting the dog's head and focus.
  • Discourages pulling and lunging, promoting calm behaviour during walks.
  • Suitable for dogs that require gentle control or have leash aggression.

Cons for this type of collar:

  • Dogs may initially resist wearing it, requiring patience and gradual acclimation.
  • Careful introduction and positive reinforcement are necessary to prevent anxiety or aversion.

Prong/Pinch Collar: 

This collar features metal prongs or pins that apply pressure around the dog's neck to discourage pulling or aggressive behaviour. The prongs distribute pressure evenly, minimizing strain on the neck.

Pros of a Prong/Pinch Collar:

  • Provides strong control over large, strong-willed dogs.
  • Minimizes strain on the neck by distributing pressure evenly.
  • Effective for dogs that pull excessively or display aggressive behaviour.

Prong/Pinch Collar Cons:

  • Improper use or excessive force can cause injury or discomfort.
  • Not suitable for dogs with sensitive necks. 

E-Collar: 

Also known as an electronic or remote training collar, it consists of a receiver worn around the dog's neck and a handheld remote control. The remote delivers various types of stimulation, such as vibrations or mild electric stimulation, allowing for the most precise communication between the owner and the dog. 

The stimulation levels can be adjusted to match the dog's sensitivity and training requirements. E-collars are versatile and suitable for off-leash training, recall commands, and behaviour modification.

Pros of an E-Collar:

  • Offers precise and consistent communication via remote control, ensuring immediate feedback.
  • Effective for off-leash training and recall commands, enhancing freedom and safety.
  • It can be adjusted to suit different training levels and sensitivities, tailoring the experience to your dog's needs.

Cons of an E-Collar:

  • Requires proper training and understanding of its correct usage.
  • Misuses, such as incorrect timing or intensity, may cause physical or emotional harm.

The E-Collar

The preferred training collar among the various dog training collars, including our trained professionals at iTK9, is the E-Collar. When used correctly, the E-Collar offers several advantages:

  1. Precision: The E-Collar allows for precise and immediate feedback to reinforce commands and behaviours, making it an excellent tool for off-leash training and advanced obedience.
  2. Customization: E-Collars come with adjustable settings, ensuring the stimulation level matches your dog's temperament and training requirements. This customization promotes a humane and tailored training experience. Remember, proper training on the various levels of an E-Collar should be conducted before using it on your pet.
  3. Versatility: The E-Collar can be used for a wide range of training purposes, including obedience, recall, and behaviour modification, offering versatility and adaptability to different training scenarios.
  4. Safety Features: Modern E-Collars are designed with safety features such as vibration or tone modes, allowing you to use the collar as a warning signal before using any stimulation. These features help ensure your dog's well-being, safety, and comfort throughout the training process.

The iTK9 Way: Training Your Pet

As a pet owner, it’s crucial that you take the time to work with and properly train your pet. This not only prevents any unforeseeable accidents from occurring but also helps to build a strong bond between you and your dog. 

If you need help working with your pet or need help figuring out where to start, our trained professionals can help. They fully commit to working with them through behaviour, obedience training, and continued learning safely and effectively. 

We do the hard work for you to attain a happy home and a healthy relationship with your pet.

Included in all of our programs are the following;

  1. In-Person Learning: Midway progress training video, two go-home lessons.
  2. Online Learning: Owner education course, instructional training videos, iTK9 member community, e-books & additional training resources.
  3. Owner Support: Photo updates of your dog training with our team and access to our team for questions & support.

Contact us today for more information on our programs, including Board & Train.

Why you shouldn’t take dog training advice from your vet

Why you shouldn’t take dog training advice from your vet

February 15, 2024

Finding an adequate source to gather dog training advice from can be complicated. You know it is important to train and work with your pet; however, you may not know where to go for the best advice.

Should you Let your Dog Sleep on the Bed with you?

Should you Let your Dog Sleep on the Bed with you?

February 7, 2024

Explore the importance of setting boundaries for your dog regarding bed sharing in our latest blog. Learn about the potential behavioral issues and sleep disturbances it can cause, and discover effective training strategies to establish healthy limits for a happier home and pet relationship. Ideal for pet owners seeking balance between affection and discipline.

iTK9: Common Reasons Why Your Dog Is Leash Reactive And How To Adjust

iTK9: Common Reasons Why Your Dog Is Leash Reactive And How To Adjust

January 24, 2024

Walking your dog should be a positive experience that fosters a deeper connection and shared joy. However, the reality for many dog owners is a walk that often involves the challenge of leash reactivity.